The Treatment of Gangrenous Diabetic Abscess by “Ring of the Dragon” Acupuncture Technique
This case-history was originally published in The Journal of Chinese Medicine, Feb. 2004
(With photographs showing the development of the treatment process)
by Shmuel Halevi Ph.D
During the past ten years I have had the opportunity to treat more than 20 cases of the Diabetic Foot syndrome in my clinic. The most difficult cases were those which developed the so-called soft- tissue abscess, or ulceration, some of which exhibited first signs of progressive gangrenous inflammation. These patients usually exhibited large ulcers, very ugly-looking and foul smelling, in various parts of the shin or foot. In most cases, they were immediate candidates for amputation, as moderate conventional Western medical modalities have failed to improve their condition. In view of this information, which is a well known fact in conventional Western medical circles, it is perhaps striking to discover that I managed to achieve a 90 % success rate in curing this syndrome by means of traditional acupuncture alone. The remaining 10% have failed treatment mostly because of immature ending of the treatment, mostly due to financial hardships. Two of the cases which I treated recently, have developed cancerous cells on the site of the abscess as well. These cases were also completely cured.
I do not pretend to claim that these few patients can present a valid and sensational statistic for the cure of this disorder, yet, it is undoubtedly worth the attention of the medical world for further investigation. It also goes without saying that there are enormous implications involved in saving an individual’s limb, as against the present widespread procedure of amputation and the patient’s subsequent suffering and incapacity.
The following case study is of a 65 year old patient of mine, Joseph, who luckily got cured of a gangrenous abscess on his left plantar surface, a “minute” before undergoing an amputation procedure. He graciously agreed to let me present a few photographs taken during the course of the treatment, showing the gradual improvement of his foot condition. I believe that this article may be of value to those acupuncturists who have had no prior experience in the treatment of such disorders. I am, unfortunately, more skeptical that this article may intrigue further investigation by any conventional medical institutions.
I came to know Joseph two years before he presented with the plantar abscess. He already was an insulin dependent diabetic, and he came to see me for recurrent attacks of gout on his left big toe and, occasionally, also on his plantar fascia. These attacks of gout, he said, started a long time before he knew he was going to have diabetes. When he came to me he was in the midst of a gout attack on his left toe, so harsh that his face was distorted with pain. Painkillers did not help much anymore, and it seemed to him that taking N.S.A.I.Ds. only made the attacks more frequent. His pulse was choppy and wiry, and his tongue scarlet-red with bulging pin-head veins underneath his tongue. The left big toe was substantially swollen, it had a purple-black-crimson-red color, bright as if polished, and was untouchable.
As understood by Western medicine, gout is the result of too much uric-acid content in the blood, due to a metabolic disorder in the break-down of purines. Purines are prevalent in red wine, anchovies, organ meat and other foods. The uric-acid crystals sink to the lower parts of the body and create a sediment in the small joints of the toes and metacarpal bones. These microscopic nail-shaped particles cause the inflammation and the severe pain typical of gout. The prevalence of renal and urinary calculi are very high in people suffering from gout, mainly due to the sedimentation and coagulation of these uric-acid crystals in the kidney tissue. 1
In traditional Chinese medical theory, the phenomenon of gout is often ascribed to damp-heat affecting the joints, at least it is often presented as such in Chinese medical schools. The logic behind that is the appearance of the gout mostly in the lower parts of the body, a typical sign of pathogenic dampness, the swelling of the affected joint and the red and hot manifestation. I disagree with this categorization. In my opinion, the disorder must be viewed in two phases. The first one, the ‘ben’ or the cause of the disease, may well be attributed to a damp-heat pathogen flowing downwards due to kidney-liver imbalance. Kidney qi, or yin, deficiency, is the basic pattern in the genesis of the gout disorder. The kidneys are too weak to eliminate the excessive heat by their separation process, thereby transmitting the pathogen down and into the liver. The liver further develops a damp-heat condition of its own, further transmitting the pathogen into the blood that it stores. When this heavy pathogen reaches the lower parts of the body, it naturally sinks into the feet articulations and creates the ‘biao’ – the manifestation of the disorder - the acute second phase. Being so closely affiliated with the blood, and having such a toxic heat quality, the pattern turns into a blood stasis disorder. Its manifestations are:
According to this analysis of the pathogenesis and nature of the gout disorder 2, I commenced with the treatment by performing a strong blood dispersion acupuncture. I bled the points Yinbai Sp-1 and Dadun Liv-1 of the affected toe with the pyramid needle, and squeezed out a few drops of black blood. I then punctured Hegu Li-4 and Sanyinjiao Sp-6 in dispersion, by quick lifting and anti-clock-wise rotation movements, until the patient could not tolerate the manipulations further. The needles were left in-situ for 30 minutes. When Joseph left for home after this session, his pain had already diminished considerably. The following day, despite the fact that he had much less pain and swelling, I repeated the same procedure, adding Quchi Li-11 to the prescription, along with Taichong Liv-3, Xingjian Liv-2 and Taibai Sp-3 on the left foot only. Quchi Li-11 strongly cools the blood and, matched with Hegu Li-4, invigorates the blood flow and disperses blood stasis. When these two points are combined with Taichong Liv-3 and Sanyinjiao Sp-6, the effect is two-fold, and especially so, if this needling is unilateral and restricted to the affected limb. It took three more consecutive sessions to eliminate the current attack completely, a fact which gained Joseph’s gratitude and trust for our future encounters.
Being worried of the evident pulse and tongue signs of a pronounced blood stasis condition in my patient, I strongly recommended to him to pursue periodical treatments, in order to eliminate future complications. To be frank, what I had in mind was possible recurrences of gout rather than toxic abscesses that may endanger the whole foot. Yet, he promised to follow my specific dietary and behavioral instructions, but could not commit himself to subsequent treatments.
About two years following the gout treatment, Joseph called me again with a desperate and urgent tone in his voice. Three weeks ago, an abscess started to develop on his left plantar surface. The abscess developed very rapidly, getting deeper and wider all the time, exuding pus and apparently, inflaming the whole foot. It did not respond to any of the treatments offered by conventional medicine and eventually, gangrene bacteria were detected in histological tests. Joseph said that the doctors were determined to amputate his left foot above the malleolus.
Leaning on my past experience with this disorder, I told Joseph that he must come for daily treatments, and that he should make up his mind urgently. In fast developing gangrene, time is of the utmost importance. Thus, Joseph came to me for a second round of emergency treatment.
He presented with a large and developed ulceration on his left plantar skin. The ulceration exuded pus and was bandaged tightly. The smell was awful and the whole foot and shin was considerably edematous and puffy. The skin around the ulceration was remarkably dark, almost black, and the rims of the wound had a rotten appearance. Joseph looked very emaciated, depressed and suffering. His pulse was very weak and thin, the Chi position very empty, but the left Cun (heart) position was wiry and Xu. The tongue was much paler than I remembered from his previous visit, yet the bulging pin-head veins underneath were still present. In overall appearance, the tongue seemed swollen and dull, coated by an excessive thick and greasy grey coating. Joseph also had a low fever.
Summary of Symptoms and Signs
Analysis and Diagnosis
Recalling Joseph’s medical history, we know that Joseph had had diabetes for several years, and that he was insulin dependent. We also know that he used to have recurrent attacks of gout, based on a kidney deficiency and a subsequent Damp-Heat condition. Diabetes mellitus, termed in Chinese Xiao-Ke (Wasting and Thirsting), is characterized in T.C.M. mainly as a Yin deficiency syndrome 3. Kidney Yin deficiency may lead to a stomach and/or lung Yin deficiencies, giving rise to the typical symptoms of excessive hunger or thirst, excessive urination and thinning of the flesh.
In Joseph’s case, the kidney yin and qi deficiency, led also to the accumulation of damp-heat pouring down and the appearance of gout. As explained above, Joseph had developed a pronounced blood stasis condition. In the acute stage, it caused the extremely painful gout attacks and in the later, chronic stage, it caused the ulceration of the skin and the formation of the abscess. Thus, the puffy and edematous foot and shin reflected ‘leg-qi’ disorder with accumulation of dampness, while the black color of the surrounding skin and the abscess itself, pointed to advanced blood stasis, to the point of decaying flesh. Hence, we can see a yang condition on the verge of turning over to a yin condition. The thin and deficient pulse qualities, the dull and lifeless tongue, the emaciation, all point to a developing deficiency condition. Yet, the bulging tongue veins, low grade fever and the inflamed abscess, mark the transition from yang to yin.
The Pathogenesis of the Abscess Flow-Chart
The Treatment Guidelines
In acute or life threatening diseases, the treatment principle is always to eliminate, as fast as possible, the acute manifestations of the syndrome. There is always time to deal with the underlying cause after the acute symptoms have disappeared. So was the treatment of Joseph’s gout attack described earlier, and in the same manner the current condition needed to be dealt with.
In view of this principle, I realized that two major efforts had to be undertaken simultaneously:
Put in Chinese terminology, I had to invigorate the blood, eliminate Fire-Toxin and drain excessive dampness. Being aware that this specific Fire-Toxin is extremely fast spreading and bears a real life threatening factor, I insisted that Joseph take an X-ray of his foot every three days. This precaution was needed in order to make sure that the gangrene had not penetrated the bone. So, in order to achieve the goals set above, I chose the following points as my opening point prescription:
Hegu Li-4 bilateral, Sanyinjiao Sp-6 and Yinlingchuan Sp-9 left side only.
Bleeding of all Jing-Well points of the left foot.
Taichong Liv-3, Neiting St-44, Xiaxi Gb-43 on the left side only.
Hegu Li-4, Sanyinjiao Sp-6 and Yinlingchuan Sp-9 served as a combination to invigorate the blood in the affected limb, and eliminate dampness. Li-4 is a major point for Qi and blood invigoration purposes throughout the whole body. This is mainly due to its role as the Yuan-source point on the Yang Ming meridian system, the richest system with Qi and blood. Sp-6 and Sp-9 form a well-established point combination for the purpose of eliminating excessive dampness, both systemically and locally.
Thus, the three points together, especially when confined to only one leg, wield a strong invigorating influence over the Qi and blood of the affected limb. Sp-6 and Sp-9 are both situated on the spleen meridian, a meridian deeply involved in the creation and spread of the internal dampness pathogen. Using these points enhances energetic activity of the spleen, tonifies its Yang Qi and eliminates dampness from the very source. Sp-6 is also very much involved in blood pathologies. It is the meeting point of the liver, spleen and kidney meridians. All these are Yin meridians belonging to three major organ entities, all of which are involved in blood creation, storage and maintenance in the body. The use of Sp-6 is therefore always utilized in blood disorders, especially those of the lower part of the body.
The bleeding of the Jing-Well points of the foot has strong blood moving, toxin eliminating properties. The Jing-Well points are almost always used in acute syndromes, usually involving the Heat or Fire pathogens. A very prevalent use of this principle, is the bleeding of Shaoshang Lu-11 in acute tonsillitis, for instance. The Jing-Well, being so anatomically close to the focus of the disease in this case, enhanced their efficacy two-fold. We saw this operate perfectly in Joseph’s gout incident, as previously described.
Taichong Liv-3, Neiting St-44, Xiaxi Gb-43 were chosen primarily because of their anatomical location near the site of the abscess. They are considered very strong and effective points, and are often chosen for various diseases. They are situated on three different meridians, all of which traverse the plantar region. Their use was, therefore, meant to affect the Qi and blood circulation in the plantar region and, for that reason, they served as a local point-cluster.
The Treatment Process
These point combinations were utilized for 10 consecutive sessions over 10 days without a break. Each session lasted 30 minutes and the needles were manipulated in dispersion every 10 minutes. Joseph was instructed to remove the bandages he had been given by the hospital, and stop applying their ointments. I forbade him from taking any further treatments suggested to him by the hospital staff, excluding the X-ray which I insisted he continue. He was told to expose the wound to the air as much as possible, except when he was traveling to see me. At home, he needed to apply a strong green tea dressing on the wound, three times a day. In addition, Joseph was requested to avoid coffee, alcohol, spicy and fried food, red meat and dairy products in addition to following his regular diabetic regime.
After five sessions the fever subsided completely and the foul smell of the abscess began to diminish. After the 10th session the swelling of the plantar region decreased, but not that of the entire ankle or the shin. The abscess started to close in, and a nice new pink flesh started to regenerate at the proximal corner, as evidenced in the following photograph.
Joseph's foot after 10 sessions
At this stage, also the black skin color started to lighten at the far margins of the inflamed mound. Also the pulse acquired more strength and was less thin and Xu.
Arriving at this stage, Joseph started to regain hope and optimism. So did his relatives, who had accompanied him to the treatments, a fact that relieved the tensed and apprehensive atmosphere which characterized the first sessions.
At this point, I decided to change the treatment prescription and shift the main effort from the Fire-Toxin detoxification to that of directly healing the wound. The points prescribed for this new purpose, were as follows:
Hegu Li-4 bilateral, Sanyinjiao Sp-6 and Yinlingchuan Sp-9 left side only (without change).
“Ring the Dragon” technique. 4
Shangqiu Sp-5, Zhaohai K-6, Jiexi St-41, Qiuxu Gb-40
The first three points were left in the prescription without any change. I considered this trio as the main “engine” for the purpose of mobilizing and invigorating Qi, blood and lymph circulation throughout the left leg and foot. I have had years of experience applying this specific combination for similar disorders with undoubted efficiency. For me, it was indispensable.
Shangqiu Sp-5, Zhaohai K-6, Jiexi St-41, Qiuxu Gb-40 were chosen as a different point-cluster, for the purpose of dispersing the pronounced edema around the ankle joint. The points were chosen particularly due to their anatomical location at the obvious spots of the edematous mounds. They were manipulated vigorously by the Huici needle technique, in order to disperse and dissolve the accumulation of dampness around the ankle. The Huici technique uses dispersion manipulations in three different angles. The needle is inserted swiftly to the deep level and twirled in a wide amplitude, and by quick withdrawals to the surface, as if pulling the Qi outward. It is then lifted to the surface and redirected, diagonally, to another angle. At this new angle the needle is manipulated again in the same fashion, and then redirected at another angle. This is performed three times persistently and then the needle is left in-situ.
However, the main acupuncture technique at this stage of the treatment, was the “Ring the Dragon” technique. By this method, the wound is being surrounded by several needles, usually between 3-6 one inch needles. The needles are placed on the healthy margins of the wound, a few millimeters away, in a slanted angle. The needle tip is advanced underneath the margin of the wound, some 1-2 cm in the direction of the center of the ulceration. It is then left in-situ without further manipulations. At the end of the session, some 30 minutes later, the “Ring the Dragon” needles are pulled out. In many instances, there are a few drops of blood exuding from the points. This slight bleeding must be encouraged by lightly pressing around the point (and not pressed to discourage bleeding). The tiny bleeding enhances micro-circulation at the rims of the abscess.
The “Ring the Dragon” method is vital in the treatment of ulcerations, boils, abscesses, scars and practically all kinds of localized skin disorders. The technique stimulates the margins of the skin problem, enhances blood circulation there, thereby accelerating the recovery of infected skin tissue. I have found this technique tremendously helpful in a wide variety of skin disorders, and in fact, it should not be overlooked in any treatment of a localized skin disease of any kind.
The above delineated needling procedure was carried out for 12 more sessions. At the 16th session, I took another photograph of Joseph’s left foot, shown below. The abscess seemed much shallower, the new pink flesh that started to form on the proximal edge had increased its dimensions, the putrid smell had almost completely disappeared and the black skin around the wound had taken a lighter shade.
Joseph's foot after 16 sessions
Throughout the last 12 sessions I occasionally introduced other points to the prescription. These were:
On the 22nd session I actually terminated the treatment, as the wound healed completely, as can be evidenced by the picture below.
Joseph's foot after 22 sessions
Joseph received four more treatments in the course of 12 days, whose aim was to resolve the remnants of the edema. This objective was completed successfully, as the ulceration, the cause for the local inflammation and congestion, had now ceased to exist.
This time, I succeeded in persuading Joseph to continue with therapy once a month, in order to keep a check on his basic condition which had allowed for the development of the ulceration. On these regular visits, he receives acupuncture treatments aimed at strengthening his Kidney-Yin and Qi and eliminating the Damp-Heat and Heat pathogens from the blood. He also self-applies regular treatments utilizing the Chopsticks Acupuncture5 technique, on points that I have marked out on his body, and keeps to a strict diet.
All in all, his condition remains stable, and the year following treatment of the ulceration, no other incidents of either gout or other ulcerations have occurred.
1. The Merck Manual on the web: http://www.merck.com/mrkshared/mmanual_home2/sec05/ch070/ch070b.jsp
2. A discussion on this topic may be found on the internet discussion forum, at: http://www.acumedico.com/discus/messages/25/129.html?1073471274 (Readers are most welcome to post their opinions and insights concerning the pathology involved in gout).
3. Diabetes Mellitus by Clinton J. Choate, JOURNAL OF CHINESE MEDICINE NUMBER 59 JANUARY 1999
4. JOURNAL OF CHINESE MEDICINE NUMBER 46 SEPTEMBER 1994, p.7
5. Chopsticks Acupuncture by Shmuel Halevi, Ph.D, Trafford publishing, B.C. Canada, Feb. 2003
Link to Dr. Halevi's homepage.